[swift-evolution] Disallowing unreachable code

John McCall rjmccall at apple.com
Mon Mar 27 12:25:22 CDT 2017

> On Mar 24, 2017, at 6:54 PM, Peter Dillinger via swift-evolution <swift-evolution at swift.org> wrote:
> I don't see anything directly relevant to this in the archives, and I haven't prepared a detailed proposal.  But I'm raising the general idea because I recently criticized Swift 3 for allowing unreachable code in a blog post: https://blogs.synopsys.com/software-integrity/2017/03/24/swift-programming-language-design-part-2/ (search for "unreachable code").  And I want you to have every opportunity to rectify this, even though I'm in the business of finding defects the compiler doesn't.  :)
> Part of my argument is that people commonly ignore compiler warnings.  We see lots of defective code that would be (or is) caught by compiler warnings but people don't pay attention.

It was, indeed, something of a policy goal for awhile to not have any compiler warnings in Swift.  The idea was that anything suspect should be an error.  We deliberately backed away from that because it was actually really disruptive to the development experience: even very conscientious programmers who diligently fix all their warnings sometimes have code "in flight", so to speak, and want to be able to test and debug it without immediately making invasive edits.  To use a germane example, if unreachable code were always an error, a programmer trying to debug a problem wouldn't be able to short-circuit a function by just adding a return; they'd also have to comment out the rest of the function.

I think we're comfortable with the current balance.  It's understood that some programmers just ignore compiler warnings, but there are costs on the other side, too.


> If you would like to see more defect examples from open-source software (other languages for the moment), I am able to dig up such things.
> Thanks
> --
> Peter Dillinger, Ph.D.
> Software Engineering Manager, Coverity Analysis, Software Integrity Group | Synopsys
> www.synopsys.com/software
> _______________________________________________
> swift-evolution mailing list
> swift-evolution at swift.org
> https://lists.swift.org/mailman/listinfo/swift-evolution

More information about the swift-evolution mailing list