[swift-evolution] [Pitch] Change the endIndex value for closed Ranges and Collections
dabrahams at apple.com
Thu Mar 24 16:24:32 CDT 2016
on Wed Mar 23 2016, Howard Lovatt <swift-evolution at swift.org> wrote:
> +1 I think it is a good idea to make a collection run from firstIndex to
> lastIndex inclusively (note name change to match firstElement and
> lastElement). For an empty collection both firstIndex and lastIndex would
> be invalid values that would cause both c[c.firstIndex] and c.[c,lastIndex]
> to fail.
That direction is pretty much a nonstarter with me. There are *many*
algorithms that are correct for empty collections without any
special-case testing, as long as you use half-open ranges. There's no
reason to make every algorithm that uses indices test for emptiness
for philosophical background on why most ranges should be half-open.
More information about the swift-evolution