[swift-build-dev] Swift Package Manager - Support for downloading/installing external dependencies that a Swift Package may have

[Ricardo N Olivieri]

Thanks Max for your response! I see what you are saying about your 
proposal having an impact on the feature we are thinking of. It would 
probably work best if we can align our feature with the changes you plan 
to include in your proposal. Do you think you will be documenting/adding 
your proposal to the list sometime this week or the following?

Regards,
   Ricardo Olivieri
   Software Engineer


From:   Max Howell <max.howell at apple.com>
To:     Ricardo N Olivieri/Austin/IBM at IBMUS
Cc:     swift-build-dev at swift.org
Date:   02/17/2016 01:30 PM
Subject:        Re: [swift-build-dev] Swift Package Manager - Support for 
downloading/installing external dependencies that a Swift Package may have
Sent by:        max.howell at apple.com



Hi Ricardo,

Respectfully I’d rather you waited, I have a proposal in the works for 
major changes to the content of Package.swift and this would have quite an 
impact on this feature.

I will try to get the proposal to the list soon.

If you want to do the PR anyway we will accept it provided it is not 
executed as a default (requiring a flag marked explicitly as temporary) 
and that we will remove the flag when the feature is properly implemented 
and integrated.

Hello Max, just following up on the previous email. Does the approach 
described in the previous message fit with the plans and vision for SPM? 
If it does and our team were to take a first shot at implementing 
something like it, would our pull request have good chances of getting 
merged with the SPM repo?

Regards,
  Ricardo Olivieri
  Software Engineer


From:        Ricardo N Olivieri/Austin/IBM
To:        Max Howell <max.howell at apple.com>
Cc:        swift-build-dev at swift.org
Date:        02/01/2016 09:12 PM
Subject:        Re: [swift-build-dev] Swift Package Manager - Support for 
downloading/installing external dependencies that a Swift Package may have


Thanks Max again for your response.

I see what you are saying about having SPM fail the build and output 
suggested commands to install the missing system-packages (as opposed to 
having SPM perform system-package installations).

We are still wondering if we could have a solution built into SPM that 
would not required any manual intervention from a human. For instance, 
would implementing something like the following be in the plans for SPM 
(this is somewhat similar to the original option #1 we shared previously)?
Swift Packages can specify dependencies on other libraries that are not 
Swift Packages (such as C libraries). The Swift Package Manager could then 
"parse" this metadata, download the C code for that external dependency 
(say, from the its GitHub repo), compile it, and make it available to 
other Swift Packages through the module.modulemap file. The metadata could 
be part of the Packages.swift file or a new file for specifying 
dependencies that are not Swift Packages.

Your thoughts?

Regards,
  Ricardo Olivieri
  Software Engineer




From:        Max Howell <max.howell at apple.com>
To:        Ricardo N Olivieri/Austin/IBM at IBMUS
Cc:        swift-build-dev at swift.org, Samuel Kallner <KALLNER at il.ibm.com>, 
Daniel Firsht/Austin/IBM at IBMUS, Andrew M Trice/Washington/IBM at IBMUS, 
Robert F Dickerson/Austin/IBM at IBMUS
Date:        01/28/2016 01:08 PM
Subject:        Re: [swift-build-dev] Swift Package Manager - Support for 
downloading/installing external dependencies that a Swift Package may have
Sent by:        max.howell at apple.com



Thanks Max for your answer. To your point, thinking about it more, it's 
probably not a great idea to have SPM execute arbitrary scripts.

It is good news to hear that something similar to option #1 could be 
implemented and that there are plans to provide something as part of SPM 
that can take of installing/downloading external [non-Swift package] 
dependencies that a Swift Package may depend on.

Does providing this functionality in SPM have a high priority? Any other 
details about the plans for this feature that could be shared at this 
point?

High-ish. There are gaping holes in SwiftPM that are currently higher 
priority.

This ticket should wait for my up-coming proposal that will improve 
module-map-packages IMO. Then we can put this in there and implement it at 
the same time.

IMO it should work like Homebrew’s caveats. If the build fails it outputs 
suggested commands to install the missing system-packages, then the user 
can type those commands in if they so choose.







-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://lists.swift.org/pipermail/swift-build-dev/attachments/20160222/b4c954e1/attachment.html>